Old School “Paladin Magic” 93-94 Rules

Legal Sets:

Decks may consist of cards from these sets printed in 1993-94:
Collector’s Edition (CE)
International Collector’s Edition (IE)
Arabian Nights
The Dark
Fallen Empires
Promotional cards from 1994 are also legal: Arena, Sewers of Estark, and Nalathni Dragon.

Additional Sets and Cards Allowed (ie. REPRINTS)
For unaltered cards we allow all non-foil cards from the sets above, that were reprinted in any language with the original frame + original art. So for example, a Chronicles City of Brass, Fifth Edition Wrath of God, Time Spiral Psionic Blast, and Collector’s Edition Mox Ruby would all be legal. (original frame + original art), while an Ice Age Icy Manipulator or Arena 1996 Counterspell would not be allowed (different art) unless they were used as a the base of an alteration see more below. The misprinted Revised Serendib Efreet (with Ifh-Biff Efreet’s art, and green border) is of course allowed, because it was printed in one of the original sets in 1994 (Revised) listed above. We always encourage you to seek out the oldest and coolest versions of cards you can find, but these can serve as your de facto substitutes for original versions of cards printed in 93-94.

Proxies: Are Allowed
In an effort to maximize creative flexibility and foster a friendly environment in our gatherings, we allow proxies for our Paladin Magic events. Both in person and online events unless specifically stated otherwise for that event. This allows an entry point to old school for interested players made hesitant by costs and infuses the format with new and creative deck ideas that were prohibitively expensive to experiment with. We encourage all players to find and own authentic cards above all others (and love them ourselves) and recognize the value this flexibility offers our fellow friends and hobbyists.

We encourage players to either make their own proxies following fair use doctrine or find & source proxies that do NOT infringe WotC, it’s artists, or affiliates. A great example of an acceptable proxy would be an artist alter made by yourself or another by hand.

Artist Proofs: Are Allowed As long as they adhere to the above referenced reprint guidelines.

Art Alters: Are Allowed
Art Alters & Proxy Guidelines:
1.) Include a written card name. A clear casting cost, and power/toughness are encouraged where appropriate.
2.) Wherever possible please include the rules text on the card or have a copy with rules text readily available to show your opponent. Not everyone has all text memorized and after all we are playing a game with nearly a thousand different playing pieces.
3.) Any reprint of a card which was printed using the original magic border may be used as a base for your art alters but may not be used “as is” as a proxy.

Deck Construction

Constructed decks must contain a minimum of 60 cards (no maximum deck size; however, you must be able to effectively shuffle your deck). If a player wishes to use a sideboard, it can contain up to 15 cards. With the exception of basic land cards (Plains, Island, Swamp, Mountain, Forest), a player’s combined deck and sideboard may not contain more than 4 of any individual card, counted by its English card title equivalent. Opaque unmarked sleeves are required for any event you attend that we organize.

The following cards are restricted in Paladin Magic 93-94 tournaments (maximum of 1 of each card per deck):
• Ancestral Recall
• Balance
• Black Lotus
• Braingeyser
• Chaos Orb
• Channel
• Demonic Tutor
• Mana Drain
• Mox Emerald
• Mox Jet
• Mox Pearl
• Mox Ruby
• Mox Sapphire
• Recall
• Regrowth
• Sol Ring
• Time Vault
• Time Walk
• Timetwister
• Wheel of Fortune
Strip Mine
Mishra’s Workshop
Mishra’s Factory 
The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale 
Maze of Ith 

The following cards are banned in Paladin Magic 93-94:
• Bronze Tablet
• Contract from Below
• Darkpact
• Demonic Attorney
• Jeweled Bird
• Rebirth
• Tempest Efreet
Mind Twist
Library of Alexandria 

The following cards are Depiction-banned in Paladin Magic 93-94:
• Invoke Prejudice
• Cleanse
• Stone-Throwing Devils
• Pradesh Gypsies
• Jihad
• Imprison
• Crusade

You can read about the original full banning of these cards by Wizards of the Coast from the entire game of magic here

We respect there are a number of differing feelings on the topic and a number of Old School clubs have handled this differently. However nearly all 93/94 formats follow modern magic card rulings, like we also do. In this spirt we are not breaking from WotC’s rules wherein they have banned these cards outright entirely from the game. It is a fairly unique situation. We have, however, devised a decent functional solution. We’re enacting a depiction ban of the cards which will allow our game spaces to be in sync with the overall magic community standards and with no real loss in the card pool. Simply much like Chaos Orb has been given an errata and we play with Mana Burn to allow for a better play experience this too aims to solve for a throwback format to fit into today’s modernized playscape. 

A depiction ban ultimately means the functionality of the cards are allowed – but not in their original format. They must be substituted with either an original altered card or an alternative proxy. The elements of these cards which must be changed are their ‘Name’ +  ‘Art box content’ as nothing about their game play mechanics is objectionable. You may not run more than 4 copies of any of these cards regardless of the alternative name you utilize. You can use a perfect fit sleeve to paint or sharpie an alter on that sleeve if you do not want to modify your physical card or print/make a new one.

Below is an example of what a depiction alternative looks like. You can easily print these off yourself at home by saving the image. If you are handy with a computer you can find better source files here Thanks to MTGCuriousities for the shared art!

Any alternative that meets our community standards and does not give you an unfair advantage is entirely welcome!

Other Notable Rules/Differences from Modern Era of Magic

– MANA BURN STILL HAPPENS (as in, players lose 1 point of life for each unused mana in the mana pool at the end of each phase)

Chaos Orb

1, Tap: Choose a nontoken permanent on the battlefield. If Chaos Orb is on the battlefield, flip Chaos Orb onto the battlefield from a height of at least one foot. If Chaos Orb turns over completely at least 360 degrees during the flip, and lands resting on the chosen permanent, destroy that permanent. Then destroy Chaos Orb.
(Note: because of how Chaos Orb is worded, with it being destroyed after a flip, it can still be Disenchanted or Shattered in response to the activation, which will nullify the ability to flip, since it is no longer on the battlefield. This is consistent with the wording of Chaos Orb not being sacrificed upon activation, as it probably would with modern templating. Also note that Chaos Orb chooses, but does not target.)

Falling Star

Choose any number of non-overlapping creatures on the battlefield. Flip Falling Star from at least a height of one foot. If Falling Star turns over completely at least 360 degrees during the flip, it deals 3 damage to each chosen creature it lands resting on. Any creatures damaged by Falling Star that are not destroyed become tapped.
(Note: Falling Star chooses upon resolution, but does not target.)

Ring of Ma’rûf

5, Tap, Exile Ring of Ma’rûf: The next time you would draw a card this turn, instead choose a card you own from exile or from your sideboard, and put it into your hand.

No Draws in Tournament Matches

In order to encourage the maximum amount of Magic and matches being played (and disincentivize draws and concession for seeding), we enforce a strict no draw policy (intentional or otherwise). After 50 minutes if there was a tied match, the tie breaker will be a sudden death Chaos Orb flipping contest, similar to a hockey or soccer overtime shootout. If both players make or miss the Chaos Orb flip in the same round, repeat the process. The first person to make it while the other person misses will be declared the winner of the match. The point of Old School is to play Old School, so we always encourage everyone to play quickly and have fun each round, and this tournament structure has worked very well to that end.